Is Black Swan Worthy of an Oscar?

In yesterday’s email from Michael Moore about State Theatre news here in Traverse City, Michigan (he helped to found the Traverse City Film Festival and restore our lovely downtown theatre), he mentioned that ‘Black Swan’ wouldn’t be playing at the State, simply because their goal is to play “Just Great Movies,” and that film didn’t make the grade.

black-swan-poster I saw ‘Black Swan’ last week, and while I liked the movie, I’m not sure it’s worthy of a Best Picture nomination. But then, I wasn’t keen on last year’s winner, ‘The Hurt Locker’ (I’ve yet to watch the entire film without falling asleep),  so what captures the attention of one person might be totally lame to the next.

I will say that Natalie Portman turns in a magnificent performance as Nina Sayers, the perfectionist ballerina who’s driven to succeed, partly because her mom (Barbara Hershey) had to drop out of the dance race when she got pregnant with Nina years earlier.

The movie isn’t so much about the cut-throat ballet industry as it is about one girl’s descent into madness. There’s also some pretty cool and creepy visual effects, which director Darren Aronofsky made the most of. Here’s a great clip about how it all came together.

Did you see and love ‘Black Swan’? Think it’s worthy of a Best Picture Oscar?


Posted

in

,

by

Comments

  1. Sheryl Avatar

    I LOVED the movie and think Natalie Portman’s performance was absolutely incredible. But, I haven’t seen all the other movies it is up against. That said, I’d be really happy if the movie – or Portman – wins the oscar.

    On another note, so thrilled to learn you are a bloggie nominee – well deserved!

  2. […] had Natalie Portman as a psycho ballerina (‘Black Swan’), Gwyneth Paltrow as an alcoholic singer (‘Country Strong’), Natalie Portman (again) as a […]

  3. […] course, Aronofsky is everywhere these days. He executive produced ‘The Fighter’ and directed ‘Black Swan,’ both of which are up for Best Picture awards at the Oscars on Feb. […]

  4. […] 100 min; official site; Facebook; buy on Amazon.Black Swan. Although I’m not sure it was truly Oscar-worthy, this psychological thriller is still a must-see for fans of director Darren Aronofsky or Oscar […]

  5. […] ‘The Hurt Locker,’ has already begun casting the film. Hopefully, it’ll be a little livelier than ‘The Hurt Locker,’ which I’ve yet to get through without falling […]

  6. […] Not much of a stretch for the red carpet “Fashion It Girl” she’s become in recent years, particularly since her memorable turn in Darren Aronofsky’s ballet thriller Black Swan. […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *