Review: What If…

what-if-movie-4 Movie:What If…
In Theaters: Aug. 20, 2010
Director: Dallas Jenkins
Runtime: 100 min.
MPAA Rating: PG for some mild thematic elements
Gecko Rating: 3 Gecko

There being a dearth of new family movies this weekend, I ended up seeing ‘What If…,” released in theaters a couple of weeks ago. You could probably classify it as a Christian movie, but even if that’s not your thing, the story offers a compelling look at those small decisions that can change the course of our lives forever.

It’s directed by Dallas Jenkins and executive produced by his dad, Jerry B. Jenkins, writer of the Gil Thorp comic strip, former editor of Moody Magazine, and author of more than 100 books. Jenkins has written and/or produced several movies since 2000, including ‘Hometown Legend.’

So you might be thinking, ok, another Christian movie in a string of recent Christian movies that includes ‘Letters to God’ and ‘To Save a Life.’ But there’s a great market for these films, and let’s face it, it’s nice to see a movie with an uplifting message that you can actually take your whole family to see. ‘What If…’ also features some veteran actors who’ve been around the Hollywood block once or twice.

Kevin Sorbo is probably best-known for his TV series ‘Hercules: The Legendary Journeys,’ or perhaps as Capt. Dylan Hunt on Gene Roddenberry’s ‘Andromeda.’ Here, he plays Ben Walker, a man who walked away from both his girlfriend Wendy (Kristy Swanson) and a call to the ministry. The story begins in a bus station, with Ben telling  Wendy that this business opportunity “will only be for a few months” and then they’ll be back together again.

Well, Ben never went back to the ministry or Wendy. Fifteen years later, he’s living in the city with a high-paying investment career, a trophy wife, and more than a few enemies. But when a car mishap lands him in a parallel universe, he wonders if he made the wrong move all those years ago.


In this parallel universe, Ben is married to Wendy, he’s the father of two kids (Toni Trucks and Taylor Groothuis), and he’s also the pastor of a small church in a small town. Sorbo seems a little out of place in this role, but by the end of the film, you can see him as a pastor and family man.

what-if-movie-2 The real coup here was landing John Ratzenberger (Cliff Claven on ‘Cheers‘) as a mechanic/angel who gently helps Ben figure out what he’s really supposed to be doing with his life. Ratzenberger makes a great angel – gruff with a heart of gold.

You don’t really know how this movie is going to end, and of course, I won’t tell you. But again, even if you tend to shy away from Christian movies, this one is uplifting and inspiring, and reminds us that one simple decision can change the course of our whole life. It’s a mix of ‘It’s a Wonderful Life’ (Ben even mentions that at one point) and ‘Blink,’ the Malcolm Gladwell book that focuses on our “adaptive unconscious” to see the truth in a split second.

Check out the ‘What If…” official site and blog, a fascinating look into the making of the film. And see the movie if you have a chance. You can even contact the filmmakers and request that it be brought to your town. You can also follow the film on Twitter.

Images: Christiano Film Group


  1. MarthaAndMe Avatar

    I hadn’t heard about this one. It sounds ok, but gosh, hasn’t this sort of concept been done, over and over?

  2. Jane Boursaw Avatar

    Brette – It really has been done a lot, which is why I only gave it 3 out of 5 Geckos. It’s kind of hard to do much more with the concept than what’s already been done (many times).

  3. MyKidsEatSquid Avatar

    It’s always funny to see actors you’ve known in other roles wind up in movies you would never have thought of them in. We saw this 1980s movie with Gary Bussey as a pomerarian–called Quigley–and while the filming was laughable, the story predictable and the special effects, well, really entertaining, it was fun to be able to watch something as a family and not worry about having to explain parts that just aren’t appropriate for kids. So did you kids enjoy the flick?

  4. Sheryl Avatar

    Don’t know if I’d see this one – although a movie that contains a little Malcolm Gladwell? That perspective sounds interesting.

  5. Alexandra Avatar

    Thanks for the tip. So many movies at the local cineplex are totally uninteresting to me, but this sounds like something I’d like. So, they borrowed the mechanic/angel from Saving Grace perhaps?

  6. Ruth Pennebaker Avatar

    I wouldn’t ordinarily see something that’s a “Christian” movie; in fact, I’d run from the box office. But this review makes me think of my own intolerance. Why *not* see something uplifting if it’s well done and not preachy?

  7. Kris Bordessa Avatar

    Hm. This doesn’t sound like a movie I’d enjoy, really. But I’m a fan of John Ratzenberger; maybe I’ll check it out if it comes to my local “cheapie” theater.

  8. Alisa Bowman Avatar

    I love movies that could go one way or another. I love What If situations. So I would probably love this, too.

  9. Jennifer Margulis Avatar

    I want to see this one! I hope it comes to our small town!!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *