Review: ‘Alice in Wonderland’ – Dreamy … and Boring?

alice_in_wonderland_poster_2 Movie: ‘Alice in Wonderland’ in 3D
Rating: PG for fantasy action/violence involving scary images and situations, and for a smoking caterpillar
Director: Tim Burton
In Theaters: March 5, 2010

“Alice in Wonderland” is both a remake and a sequel of sorts. It finds 19-year-old Alice (Mia Wasikowska) returning to the fantasy underworld that she visited as a child. Only she thinks it’s all a dream, and doesn’t understand when the characters down there keep saying she’s “back.”

But first, let’s talk about how she got there. The story opens with Alice being driven in a horse-drawn carriage to what we (and she, apparently) soon learn is to be her engagement party. Hamish (Leo Bill) seems like the perfect catch for that particular era – he’s a lord, he has money, and the marriage would free Alice’s mother of being responsible for her into adulthood. That’s the way things went back then. You didn’t necessarily marry for love in the 19th century.

But Alice isn’t so sure about all of this. Her father was a wealthy man and entrepreneur who planned to explore profitable shipping routes throughout the world. Alice has that same independent spirit, which is why she feels trapped in this restricted world.

Cue the white rabbit wearing the waistcoat. Alice sees him in the bushes, and ditches Hamish during his proposal (with the expectant crowd looking on) to run off and find the rabbit (voiced by Michael Sheen). She falls down the rabbit hole and enters a world both strange and wonderful.


We meet the Mad Hatter (Johnny Depp), the evil Red Queen (Helena Bonham Carter), her gentle sister the White Queen (Anne Hathaway), the Knave of Hearts (Crispin Glover), the Cheshire Cat (Stephen Fry), a smoking blue caterpillar (voiced by Alan Rickman), fat boys Tweedledee and Tweedledum (voiced by Matt Lucas), and various other odd creatures.

The movie is an interesting mix of real people, CG-enhanced people (the Red Queen has Carter’s face, but her enormous head and tiny body are computer-generated), and CG-animated creatures, like the Tweedles and the Cheshire Cat. You’re sort of scratching your head as to how it all came together, but I’m sure they’ll explain the process in a bonus feature when the DVD comes out.

The movie is available in both 3D and traditional formats. I saw the 3D format, and kept taking my glasses off to see what was 3D – because a lot of it didn’t really seem 3D-ish (though parts of it definitely were). I’d like to see the traditional format and see if there really is much difference.

As for the story, it sort of meanders along in a dream-like state and lags a bit somewhere around the time that Alice ends up at the Red Queen’s palace (about half-way through the movie). Mia Wasikowska is a beautiful girl who plays Alice with equal parts skepticism, wonder and annoyance. But she’s a little boring. I’d have to say that Anne Hathaway as the White Queen falls into the category, too.

The bright spot is Johnny Depp and Helena Bonham Carter, who’ve collaborated so many times with Tim Burton that they can probably read each others’ thoughts. They’re interesting and fun, not to mention quite colorful. Every time those two are onscreen, you can’t help but watch.

‘Alice in Wonderland’ is an interesting movie, though I wouldn’t call it fantastic. But I love the ultimate message – that Alice doesn’t have to marry for any other reason than love, and can boldly venture off to do her own thing, despite what others’ think about it. That’s a good message, not only in the 19th century, but also present day.

alice_in_wonderland_2 alice-in-wonderland-6 alice-in-wonderland-2 alice-in-wonderland-3 alice-in-wonderland-4

Images: Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures


5 responses to “Review: ‘Alice in Wonderland’ – Dreamy … and Boring?”

  1. Sheryl Avatar

    Thanks for the thorough description and the wonderful photos, Jane. But even though the story and cast is terrific, I think I’ll sit this one out…

    1. Jane Boursaw Avatar

      Sheryl – Yeah, I think this would be a good one to get on DVD. I’m sure they’ll pack it with plenty of bonus features.

  2. Susan Avatar

    From what I’ve seen in ads, it looks visutally stunning. But it’s a very familiar story, so I’m not sure how incredible the movie could really be. Maybe I’ll Netflix it!

  3. Alexandra Avatar

    Thanks for this review. The colors are gorgeous! I like the main actors, so will probably watch it on Netflix, too.

  4. Maya Avatar

    i love tim burton and everything but this movie was just so boring.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *