Should you bring
the kids? Yes, but best for kids 12 and older due to a few
scenes of gang violence. For more info, see "Bringing the Kids"
below.
THE STORY:
This movie tells the real-life story of Erin Gruwell (Hilary Swank),
a fresh-faced young teacher whose first assignment is teaching
at-risk kids who've been written off by the system.
It's the fall of
1994, in Room 203 at Woodrow Wilson High School in Long Beach,
California. Swank's portrayal of Gruwell is giddy and girlish, and
you get the feeling she's a lamb being led to slaughter. The other
teachers scoff at the notion that she'll actually teach these kids
something. They also advise her NOT to wear the pearls her Dad gave
her, but she does anyway. I think she wants to show the students she
trusts them.
The students: a mix
of African-American, Latino, Cambodian, Vietnamese, and Caucasian
kids. Many have grown up in rough neighborhoods and know violence
first hand. They have three things in common: they hate school, they
hate Gruwell, and they hate each other. The mood in L.A. is tense,
too, with the Rodney King riots and O.J. Simpson trial fresh in
peoples' minds.
Instead of giving
up, Gruwell moonlights at other jobs to buy the kids books (the
administration won't let them use school books – they'll "ruin"
them). So she buys
the
books herself: "Night" by Elie Wiesel, "Anne Frank: The Diary of a
Young Girl," and "Zlata's Diary: A Child's Life in Sarajevo," by
Zlata Filipovic.
The students –
played by April Hernandez, Rock Anthony, Dre Bowie, and others --
are none too thrilled about reading, but they soon discover that the
authors' lives were much like their own – filled with violence. One
day, Gruwell dumps a stack of blank notebooks on her desk, and the
students start writing diaries about their everyday lives: gangs,
immigration, drugs, violence, abuse, and suicide are the hot topics.
The kids'
enthusiasm grows, and they name themselves "The Freedom Writers," in
honor of the Civil Rights leaders, the Freedom Riders. Soon, those
once apathetic, frustrated kids evolve into a close-knit, motivated
family. They raise funds and arrange for visits from Zlata Filipovic
and Miep Gies (Pat Carroll), the courageous Dutch woman who
sheltered the Frank family during WWII. The teens also raise money
to visit the Holocaust Museum in Washington, D.C., where they
present their diary to Secretary of Education Richard Riley.
Sub-plots involve Erin's father (Scott
Glenn), a wealthy man who doesn't understand his daughter's
passion for these kids. Patrick Dempsey plays her husband, a guy
who's struggling to find his own path and who isn't very supportive
of her teaching.
NOTE: In
1998, the real-life Freedom Writers won the Spirit of Anne Frank
Award and traveled to New York for the acceptance ceremony. And in
1999, they traveled
to
Europe and visited Anne Frank's house in Amsterdam, the
concentration camps in Germany and Poland, and their friend, Zlata,
in her native Sarajevo, Bosnia.
THE WRAP-UP:
Inspiring, moving, and hopeful, this movie
reinforces the idea that one person really CAN make a difference,
both in their community and in the greater world. The goal of The
Freedom Writers is to help kids form a community where they feel
safe, accepted, and understood. The Web site,
www.gruwellproject.org offers good insight on how kids and
teachers can make a difference.
BRINGING THE
KIDS:
PRESCHOOLERS
(ages 2-5): The themes in this movie are too intense for little
ones, but it's never too early to teach kids the value of connecting
with other people. Check out "Postcards From Buster," the TV series
about a little bunny who sends video postcards home to his friends
while flying around the country with his dad. Touting cultural
awareness, this thoughtful series shows that even though we all live
in different places, perhaps we’re not so different after all.
GRADE-SCHOOLERS
(ages 6 - 10): With drugs, violence and other gritty themes,
this movie is too disturbing for most grade-schoolers. Language
includes at least one "f" word and some milder expletives. A better
choice is the PG-rated "Akeelah and the Bee," about a girl living in
a poor section of L.A. who overcomes her fears to compete in the
National Spelling Bee. Like the kids in "Freedom Writers," Akeelah
learns that words can change the world.
TWEEN / TEEN (ages 11+):
The great thing about this movie is that
it doesn't romanticize anything about life in a poor, racially
charged area, where just getting through the day alive is an
accomplishment. But no matter where they live, kids can always use
an extra hand to help guide them. They need to know it's ok to ask
for help.
SCORE:
3.5 out of 4 Reels